Labor punching on health but copping it back harder

John Kidman and Nick Wilson |

Labor has promised emergency patient transport staff will be able to transfer long service leave.
Labor has promised emergency patient transport staff will be able to transfer long service leave.

Frontline Victorian health workers will suffer under an Americanised system should the coalition or One Nation win office, Labor claims.

The swipe is at the heart of separate government pledges to protect the state’s nurses, paramedics and patient transport drivers.

However national health advocacy organisations are reserving much of their vitriol towards various policy positions for Labor, in the lead up to the November 28 election.

At the top of the list is a government decision following a review in December, to absorb VicHealth into the Department of Health.

Opposition leader Jess Wilson has committed to retaining the statutory authority’s independence in a move that has won support from both the Public Health Association and Australian Medical Association.

Ben Carroll
Ben Carroll has accused the Liberals and One Nation of trying to “Americanise” health in Victoria. (Christopher Hopkins/AAP PHOTOS)

“VicHealth is the world’s first health promotion foundation,” according to the PHA.

“It is a leader in tackling the health consequences of harmful industries such as alcohol, tobacco, vaping and gambling.”

As such, it should be a fully funded stand-alone body.

The Greens and One Nation have also fallen into line with the call, leaving the government as a political outlier.

However, the coalition also wants a fresh VicHealth focus on more conventional preventative concerns like immunisation and healthy diets rather than tackling social ills.

Embattled Premier Ben Carroll came out swinging albeit with smaller targets in mind on Saturday.

If re-elected next weekend, he promised $14.4 million to guarantee emergency patient transport staff would be able to transfer their long service leave instead of having to start over when they change jobs.

He also declared “health is on the ballot this election” with a pledge to save the jobs of 132 nurses he says are in the coalition’s sights at Werribee Mercy Hospital in Melbourne’s southwest 

“The Liberals went to war with paramedics the last time they were in government,” he said.

“Now they’ll make $40 billion in cuts and One Nation wants to privatise hospitals.

“Together, they will Americanise our health system – so your credit card matters more than your Medicare card.”

However the Australian Medical Association remains steadfast in its demands over VicHealth.

Slevin
Public Health Association boss Terry Slevin says Victorians are scarred by the COVID-19 pandemic. (Mick Tsikas/AAP PHOTOS)

It points out that eminent health scientists Sir Gustav Nossal and professors Fiona Stanley and Rob Moodie also wrote to Mr Carroll and Ms Wilson expressing the same concerns.

Health association boss Terry Slevin says Victorians remain the most deeply scarred Australians off the back of the COVID-19 pandemic.

“This was due to the stripped-out public health and prevention capacity over years of disinvestment,” he said last week.

“Victorians deserve better from their next government”.

The latest RedBridge Group/Accent Research survey, published in the Australian Financial Review, puts the Liberal-National coalition on 31 per cent, Labor down one point to 23 per cent and One Nation hot on its heels at 22 per cent.

Senior recruit Barnaby Joyce has meanwhile declared One Nation will need a quarter of upper-house seats and a proportionate swag in the lower chamber to claim victory.

The former deputy prime minister says his party has plenty of community support but is marching uphill towards November 28. 

One Nation
Barnaby Joyce says One Nation expects Labor preference to go against this party in Victoria. (Lukas Coch/AAP PHOTOS)

“We’re not up against the Liberal coalition and we’re not up against socialists,” he told AAP, referring to the opposition and Labor. 

“We’re up against the socialist-Liberal coalition because their votes combine.”

Mr Joyce predicts Labor will place third in a slew of seats, leaving the Liberals and Nationals vying with One Nation for pole position.

Labor’s main contribution would therefore be its preferences, which he expects will disadvantage One Nation.

“We don’t have to beat one,” he said. 

“We have to beat two.”

AAP