‘Dirty tricks’: Labor accused of duping early voters
Nick Wilson |
Victorian Labor has been accused of misleading voters by distributing how-to-vote cards targeting Greens voters in certain seats.
The cards, distributed at select early voting centres and bearing the authorisation of the party’s state secretary Steve Staikos, direct voters to put the Greens first and Labor second.
But in Point Cook and Tarneit, two suburban Melbourne seats the Labor handouts have targeted, the Greens are running open tickets.

This means their how-to-vote cards only direct voters to put the minor party first and leave the rest blank.
The Greens claim the materials, which loosely resemble its own campaign materials, are designed to mislead voters.
“If Labor wants to win back voters who are turning to the Greens, it should come up with better policies, not resort to desperate, pathetic political games,” a Greens spokesperson told AAP.
“Victorians deserve an election fought on ideas, not misleading how-to-vote cards, dirty tricks and backroom preference deals.”

Clancy Moore, chief executive at Transparency International Australia, agreed the tactic risked misleading and deceiving voters.
He stressed it must be viewed in light of Victoria’s political transparency settings, noting the state has no truth in political advertising laws.
“You can effectively lie to voters during election campaigns,” he said, speaking generally and not about Labor’s how-to-vote cards.
“There are really low levels of trust in our political systems, our elections (and) information more broadly.
“If you have candidates and political parties trying to deceive voters, it just further erodes trust.”

Premier Ben Carroll did not directly address the matter when asked why Labor volunteers had been tasked with distributing them.
“We’re making sure every Victorian, no matter where their community is, knows you must put Labor number one,” he told reporters on Thursday.
Labor’s Point Cook MP Mathew Hilakari defended the move, claiming it was clear they came from Labor and the suggested preferences had been well-received by Greens volunteers.
“One of their campaigners came to me this morning, had a look at the card and said ‘I’ll be handing out these alongside my card too’,” he said, according to ABC.
“When you’ve got Greens volunteers handing out the Labor-authorised ticket, that says where they’re thinking the Greens are up to.”

It served as a reminder voters should examine the fine print when reading how-to-vote materials, Monash political scientist Zareh Ghazarian said.
“Many Australians do rely on … how-to-vote cards, to fill out their ballot papers,” he said.
“These are significant documents.”
He said using look-alike voting materials risked backfiring on political parties and feeding into negative perceptions surrounding transparency.
A Victorian Electoral Commission spokesperson said the voting authority did not speak on specific matters.
They said how-to-vote cards distributed at early voting centres do not need to be registered with the commission but were still subject to certain legal requirements.
Mr Moore said all how-to-vote materials should be required to be registered, noting almost two thirds of Victorians are expected to vote before election day.
“It seems to be a glaring omission,” he said.

It comes as the election commission grapples with an incident at a Richmond voting centre during the first day of early voting on Wednesday.
An unauthorised individual, who presented as a VEC casual, gained access to the centre after staff failed to verify their credentials, according to the commission.
Electoral commissioner Sven Bluemmel said sealed ballot boxes containing some 700 votes were isolated as a precaution but stressed the integrity of the voting process was not compromised.
Both major parties continue to campaign in the lead-up to the November 28 poll, which polling suggests is Opposition Leader Jess Wilson’s to lose.
AAP