‘Disgrace’: skip bin discovery a human welfare concern

Tom Wark, Trevor Marshallsea and Callum Godde |

So You Are (gold cap) fell ill after finishing eighth in the Melbourne Cup, behind Point Of Law.
So You Are (gold cap) fell ill after finishing eighth in the Melbourne Cup, behind Point Of Law.

As Melbourne Cup runner So You Are’s owner-breeder calls for heads to roll over the horse’s discovery in a skip, an expert has pushed back on claims the story is an indictment on animal welfare.

Stuart Ramsey says it is a “bloody disgrace” the gelding was left in the skip bin while awaiting burial at Sydney’s Cleanaway Lucas Heights Resource Recovery Centre.

The grisly sight was uncovered by a Sydney builder, with online footage outraging industry participants and anti-horse racing activists alike.

Trainer Bjorn Baker’s promising stayer – who earned $1.4 million from eight career wins – took ill at a spelling farm after finishing eighth in Australia’s most famous race on November 3.

Bjorn Baker.
Bjorn Baker says he and his staff were distressed to hear of So You Are’s death and its aftermath. (Chris Hopkins/AAP PHOTOS)

“There should be a full investigation. Heads have got to roll – simple as that,” Ramsey told AAP.

“He was more than just a racehorse. He brought our family together, and to think of the stress the family are under now because of this – it’s a bloody disgrace.

But Charles Sturt University equine scientist Cath Henshall said she was not shocked to see So You Are’s final fate.

“It is very common for horses that have been euthanised … to be disposed of in landfill,” Dr Henshall told AAP.

“What I found surprising just was that the body was in a skip bin rather than having been buried.”

He was rushed to the REC Equine Specialists veterinary clinic at Horsley Park in Sydney’s west after showing signs of colic on Monday morning. 

Surgery could not save the horse and he was euthanised under anaesthesia.

Melbourne Cup
This year’s Melbourne Cup proved to be the last outing for gelding So You Are (gold cap, 16). (Con Chronis/AAP PHOTOS)

REC managing partner Jonathan Lumsden said the centre had spoken with So You Are’s owners and trainers to apologise.

He pointed out the veterinary practice did not carry out the burial but took “full responsibility” for choosing the service provider and arrangements.

“He should have been promptly and respectfully buried,” Lumsden said in a statement.

Ramsey, who said he hadn’t been contacted by REC, wasn’t satisfied with their explanation. 

“They should take responsibility. It wasn’t the contractor’s fault; it was their fault,” he said.

The company who operates the landfill where the gelding was found said the discovery was not evidence of a breach of process.

“The horse carcass delivered to the facility arrived in a small tipper truck, which is not permitted on the landfill tipping face for safety reasons,” a Cleanaway spokesman said.

“In accordance with established procedures, the deceased horse was transferred into a skip bin to enable its safe disposal at the landfill.”

Ramsey declared racehorses among the best looked-after animals in the world and spoke of his affinity for So You Are.

However, the treatment of So You Are’s remains has sparked strong criticism from animal welfare groups.

“This is business as usual for an industry where profit is always more important than sentiment,” Coalition for the Protection of Racehorses campaign director Elio Celotto told AAP.

Dr Henshall dismissed the claim that So You Are’s story was evidence of ongoing animal welfare concerns.

“Once the animal has died, and provided it was treated humanely beforehand … it no longer has a welfare,” the academic said.

“It no longer has an interest in what happens to its body because it can’t feel what’s happening to its body.

“It becomes a human welfare issue because we don’t like seeing dead animals, or we’re distressed by the sight of dead animals.”

Racing NSW said “appropriate action” would be taken if any wrongdoing was discovered in its ongoing investigation.

Industry guidelines state a licensed landfill is the preferred option for animals who have died via euthanasia, due to the chemicals involved in the process.

“That burial, however, should have occurred in a timely and respectful manner,” a Racing NSW statement said.

Baker said he was also left deeply distressed by the handling of the much-loved horse’s remains, adding they deserved to be treated with dignity and respect.

AAP