Trump can keep National Guard deployed to LA for now
Brad Brooks and Luc Cohen |
A US appeals court is allowing President Donald Trump to maintain his deployment of National Guard troops in Los Angeles amid protests over stepped-up immigration enforcement, temporarily pausing a lower court ruling that blocked the mobilisation.
The 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals’ decision does not mean the court will ultimately agree with Trump, but it does leave command of the Guard with the president for now.
Earlier on Thursday, San Francisco-based US District Judge Charles Breyer found that Trump’s deployment of the Guard was unlawful.
Breyer had ordered the National Guard to return to the control of California Governor Gavin Newsom, who had brought the case.
It was a brief victory for Newsom, as Breyer’s order was paused a short time later.
The three-judge panel that paused the ruling said it would hold a hearing on Tuesday to consider the merits of Breyer’s order.
The appeals court decision stands to leave in place the dynamic of week-long street demonstrations that have been concentrated in downtown Los Angeles, largely at a federal detention centre where National Guard troops have stood watch.
The Guard had also accompanied Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents on operations.
In his ruling, Breyer wrote that the presence of the troops in the city was itself inflaming tensions with protesters – a contention made by Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass, among others -and depriving the state of the ability to use the Guard for other purposes.
That ruling came hours after Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem pledged to “liberate” Los Angeles at a media conference that was dramatically interrupted when federal agents dragged Democratic US Senator Alex Padilla out of the room, forced him to the ground and handcuffed him.
The court battle and press conference scuffle underscored the political polarisation generated by Trump’s hardline approach to immigration enforcement and expansive use of presidential power.
Trump is carrying out a campaign promise to deport immigrants, employing forceful tactics consistent with the norm-breaking political style that got him elected twice.
Between the rulings, Newsom said the National Guard would be redeployed to its previous tasks, including border security, preparing for wildfires and countering drug smuggling.
But the Trump administration immediately appealed the judge’s order, calling Breyer’s ruling “an extraordinary intrusion on the President’s constitutional authority as commander in chief”.
Trump justified the deployment of troops by characterising the protests in Los Angeles as a “rebellion”, but Breyer said in a temporary restraining order that the protests fell far short of that legal standard.
“The court is troubled by the implication inherent in defendants’ argument that protest against the federal government, a core civil liberty protected by the First Amendment, can justify a finding of rebellion,” Breyer wrote.
Trump has said if he had not ordered in the National Guard the city would be in flames.
The protests so far have been mostly peaceful, punctuated by incidents of violence and restricted to a few city blocks.
Trump summoned the National Guard on Saturday, then the US Marines on Monday, to help federal police forces guard federal buildings from protesters and to protect federal immigration agents as they picked up suspected violators.
Reuters
